I0 abstract the choice to breastfeed rather than formulafeed an infant as well as the duration of doing so has been scrutinized in more recent times. The levels of protein in cows milk are much higher 50% to 75% greater than in human milk. The purpose of the present study was to investigate and compare the antifungal effect of human milk with infant formula and cows milk. The influence of early infantfeeding practices on the. Effects of breastfeeding compared with formulafeeding on. The fat and lactose, respectively, provide 50% and 40% of the total energy of the milk 11. Formula is mostly made from parts of cows milk that have been altered to make it a bit easier to digest than straight cows milk. One of the amazing things about breast milk is that your milk is specially formulated to have the right composition for your baby, and to. In 2012, we published the first metabolomic analysis on bm samples, reporting interesting data on its composition and relevant differences with formula milk fm, useful to improve fm composition.
Mataix verdu 8 for cows milk, and breast milk from the nutrition treatise of angel gil. Comparison of calorie and protein intake of very low birth weight infants receiving mothers own milk or donor milk when the nutrient composition of human milk is measured with a breast milk analyzer. While other components of breast milk vary widely between wellnourished and poorly nourished mothers, the amount of lysozyme is conserved, suggesting that it is very important. One of the very first decisions new parents make, even before the baby is born, is how to feed their infant. The highest concentration is found in colostrum, the premilk that is only available from the breast the first three to five days of the babys life.
May 11, 2017 is there a difference between infant formula vs. Depending on what the mother eats, the breast milk has a wide range of flavors, which allow the bay to try new foods later on whereas formulas have different specific tastes which dont allow for such a large range of taste for baby early on. Comparison of breast milk and infant formula composition appendix a shows the composition of early breast milk, mature milk and two infant formulas. What are the nutritional differences between commercial. Breast milk provides protection for the baby until a babys own immune system is fully functional 8 9. Comparing infant formulas with human milk infant formula. One is to choose whether to breastfeed your baby or bottle feed using infant formula. Dec 16, 2015 parity is the strongest predictor of delayed onset of copious milk production with a prevalence of delayed onset to be 33% among primiparous versus 5% among multiparous mothers. Metabolite profiles of formula milk compared to breast. Hmo contain between 3 to 22 saccharide units per molecule, and are made up of 5 different sugars, found in varying. Breast milk is much more easily digested than formula.
For one thing, each babys breast milk is unique to just them, whereas there are a variety of different formula brands, but they arent tailored to you or your babe. This may lead you to believe that formula is more nutritious for your baby, but thats not the case. Breast milklike infant formula stirs debate the conversation. Bottlefed babies receive the exact same nutrients every time they eat. All formula milks are a mix of proteins derived from cows or goats milk, fat mainly vegetable oils, carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals, and the actual composition of infant formula and followon formulas is strictly regulated under the uk infant formula. Staff report information only composition of breast. Neither whole milk nor skim milk is an acceptable alternative for infant feeding.
Healt experts believe breast milk is the best nutritional choice for infants. Rich in brain building omega 3s, namely dha and automatically adjusts to infants needs and levels decreases as baby gets olderrich in cholesterolnearly completely absorbed. This means mom may find herself in demand every 2 or 3 hours maybe more, maybe less in the first few weeks. This means mom may find herself in demand every 2 or 3 hours maybe more, maybe less in. Comparison of human milk, cows milk and infant formulas for their antifungal effects against environmental fungi aim. Infant formula manufacturers have made changes to formulas in order to match either human milk composition or breastfeeding performance benson and masor, 1994. It is poorly digested and may cause bleeding of the gastrointestinal. Breast milk, on the other hand, continually changes in composition so that your baby gets what he or she needs at any age. The following chart compares the composition of formula to that of human breast milk. Cows milk and cows milk formula are made for just thata baby cow it is species specific for a growing calf. Choosing whether to breastfeed or formula feed their baby is one of the biggest decisions expectant and new parents will make. Dont breastfeed if you have aids, herpes, or if you do drugs, which includes smoking cigarettes. The benefits of breastfeeding across the early years of childhood. Moreover, breastfeeding is not a monolithic activity of given duration and intensity, and is often undertaken in conjunction with some formula feeding.
And breastfed babies do need to eat more often than babies who are fed formula, because breast milk digests faster than formula. But breastfeeding may not be possible for all women. Breast milk helps the immature immune system develop normally 10. Infant formula, baby formula or just formula american english or baby milk, infant milk or first milk british english, is a manufactured food designed and marketed for feeding to babies and infants under 12 months of age, usually prepared for bottlefeeding or cupfeeding from powder mixed with water or liquid with or without additional water. Fresh cows milk should only be introduced after 1 year of age. This book discusses the basic composition of human milk and explains the significant causes of variations in vitamins, minerals, and macronutrients. The effects of formula feeding on preterm infant body composition from term to 12month corrected age are inconclusive in our study.
However, bovine milk contains higher levels of fat, minerals and protein compared to human breast milk. Did you know that the nutrient composition of your breast milk changes throughout each feed every time you breastfeed. The benefits of breastfeeding across the early years of. Formula can be life saving in certain situations but there is absolutely no research and common sense will tell you to support the idea that a toddler should be switched to a milk which is for a different species instead of. There is a growing trend to pass on misinformation suggesting that formula milk actually harms babies. The fundamental composition of breast milk includes, protein, salt, and sugar, which are all contained in a fat suspension. All types of immunoglobulins are found in human milk. Breast milk prevents many diseases in the breastfed infant thanks to its perfect balance of vitamins, minerals and nutrients, both in the early weeks and long term. Constituents of human milk by ann prentice, from food and nutrition bulletin the united nations university press1996 december. I understand that youre not advocating cows milk for infants, however, i do believe that a homemade raw cows milk formula is far better than storebought generic formula if the mother is unable to breastfeed for some reason. Officially, the world health organization who designates formula milk as the last choice in infantfeeding. With regard to the breast milk and cows milk composition table, data have been extracted from the spanish food composition table. Human breast milk contains lysozyme a potent digestive ingredient at a level thirty times higher than in any formula.
Ingredients in breastmilk versus artificial breastmilk. Also, do not drink more than 5 cups of coffee or drink excessive amounts of alcohol disclaimer advantages of breast milk by. Comparison of human milk, cows milk and infant formulas for. As a new parent, you have many important decisions to make.
Many of these cannot be found in formula immunoglobulins. Staff report information only composition of breast milk. Infants should not be fed fresh cows milk, as the nutritional composition has not been modified to suit infants needs. Comparison of human milk, cows milk and infant formulas. Metabolite profiles of formula milk compared to breast milk. Newkirk, melanie shakeel, fauzia parimi, prabhu rothpletzpuglia, pamela patusco, rachael marcus, andrea fleisch and brody, rebecca 2018.
Roughly 6065% of infants in america are breastfed as newborns, and over 73% of them transition to infant formula between birth and 6 months of age. This is very revealing of how inadequate formula is compared to human milk or even cows milk. Influences on compositional differences of human milk include maternal and environmental factors and the expression andmanagement. Cow milk based infant formula contains added vegetable oils, vitamins, minerals. Developed by the douglas college for the breastfeeding course for health care providers, this eye opening comparison of breast milk ingredients and formula ingredients is astounding please understand that this article has not been published so formula feeding mothers can feel guilty. There are a number of breastmilk components that are extremely beneficial to babies development. Composition of human breast milk human breast milk is a complex matrix with a general composition of 87% water, 3. The variation in milk composition between species is one of them.
They recommend that babies feed only on breast milk for the first 6 months, and then continue to have breast. Breastfeeding vs formula difference and comparison diffen. However, the composition of human breast milk is dynamic and changes over time. Cows milk more similar to human milk than formula, but with great compositional and structural differences for example, human babies cannot digest cows milk proteins, and baby cows would not be able to survive on human milk. However, as you can see from the chart there are many differences between the two. Health experts agree that breastfeeding is the healthiest option for both mom and baby. Explain the difference between breast milk and formula in terms of flavors and introduction of new foods.
Caring for a baby with cows milk allergy enfamil us. The decision to breastfeed or formula feed a baby is a personal decision each and every family will have to make together. Formula research paper choosing whether to breastfeed or bottle feed is one of the first choices mothers have to make. Breastfeeding vs formula or bottle feeding and the risk of. Aug 21, 20 formula milk only contains alphatocopherol, which is the most abundant of the vitamin e molecules in our body and diet, whereas breast milk contains a much lower amount of vitamin e, but it is made up of all eight molecules providing a broader spectrum of benefits. While there is strong evidence that breast is best, a new study suggests that the benefits have been overstated, and may be mostly due to nonspecific factors such as better education and overall health care. Compared with breastfeeding, formula feeding is associated with altered body composition from birth to term in preterm infants. Human milk oligosaccharides hmo are an important component of human milk carbohydrate, and are the third largest component in breast milk, totalling on average 12.
Breastfeeding is generally accepted as the optimal method of feeding infants. A nuanced view on breast vs formula sciencebased medicine. The benefits of breastfeeding across the early years of childhood clive r. Compromises have to be made between the physiological constraints to milk synthesis and selective pressures to maximize offspring survival. Many mothers do not realize there is a difference between breast milk and formula. Infant formula is made to suit the physiological needs of infants. Unless youve been living under a rock which honestly sounds sort of blissful sometimes, youre aware that this is a hot topic in the mommy sphere. Is there a difference between breast milk and formula. Breast milk and formula milk compositions cocoscience. Breast milk contains over 200 nutritional, as well as functional, components. Breastfeeding is recommended by the american academy of pediatrics. Rarely, an infant with cows milk allergy reacts severely to cows milk protein. Nutrition from a nutritional perspective, numerous components found in breast milk are also in infant formula.
Therefore, cow milk must be skimmed and diluted to more closely resemble human breast milk composition 34,35. Human milk and formula ingredient list now also available in romanian at. Aug 23, 2011 breast milk like infant formula stirs debate august 23, 2011 9. All formula milks are a mix of proteins derived from cows or goats milk, fat mainly vegetable oils, carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals, and the actual composition of infant formula and followon formulas is strictly regulated under the uk infant formula and followon formula england regulations 2007. One of the amazing things about breast milk is that your milk is specially formulated to have the right composition for your baby, and to contain exactly the right amounts of nutrients. The term breastfeeding performance is used because, with the exception of one study of preterm infants lucas et al. Human milk and infant formula focuses on human milk and infant formula as the major sources of infant food. Jan 02, 2018 after more than 15 years of effort, this study puts to rest the controversy regarding the potential role of cows milk formula in the development of type 1 diabetes, said dr. These two lists were developed by cecily heslett, sherri hedberg and haley rumble as a student project for the breastfeeding course for health care providers at douglas college in new westminster, bc, canada in 2007. Whole milk of cow if your baby is under a year old as heshe may develop an allergic reaction foods that are high in sweet, salt or fats. Apr 25, 2005 april 25, 2005 breast milk may be best, breast milk may be best, but there is more evidence that women who cant breastfeed can give their babies a boost by feeding them formulas fortified with.
However, breast feeding is not always possible for all women, and the choice whether to breast feed or use formula is a personal one. Ingredients in breastmilk versus artificial breastmilk formula. Breast milk exclusive breastfeeding widely recommended optimal nutrition for health, growth and development a highly complex mixture of nutrients dissolved or emulsified in water human milk composition is influenced by. Belfield and inas rashad kelly nber working paper no. Marsupial milk, nevertheless, can be very high in carbohydrates, but the sugars are primarily oligo and polysaccharidesrich in galactose. For many, the decision to breastfeed or formula feed is based on their comfort level. In addition to those nutrients breast milk also provides the infant with immune factors, growth and hormone factors, and enzymes. A big decision new moms must make for their little ones nutrition is breast vs. Comprised of nine chapters, this monograph starts with an overview of the benefits of. Ever been curious as to whats found in breast milk and what ingredients can be found in formula.
215 526 4 826 135 762 1385 916 506 1405 502 13 247 1529 538 946 550 645 635 1197 441 206 932 439 667 955 132 1500 659 767 632 424 661 148 1485 918 1144 742 373 942 138 277 1116 897 1392 644 1240 1055